Tony you are pretty right in your thinking here. Only thing is when you bring up the the part about a incentive for being a standout hard worker or just being a lazy POS is flawwed in a way. It depends on what type of union you are reffering too. For example, a Union like the autoworkers or twinkie makers, they have a year round job and damn well now they cant get fired or lose there job, so YES they are not going to do anymore than they have to or anymore than the next guy because they are making the same on the hour etc... BUT here is where your theory is wrong, in a skilled trades union like the carpenters, electricians, boilermakers, ironworkers, insulators, etc.. we do not have steady year round work so when we get to the job if you want to keep your job for as long as possible you have to stand out and bust your ass. Because if you dont bust your ass you will get laid off and the employer will call the union hall and have someone sent out on the job the very next day to replace your lazy ass. And when that happens then the union hall will probably not send you on another job for along time. I think you get my point here, the union jobs that have steady year round work like police, teachers and factory workers are full of lazy worthless workers and i agree these unions need to be removed or seriously converted over into a new way of doing things. But the skilled trades unions you DO NOT have the same scenario you do not have the lazy people because they wont have a job if they are. Almost like there should be 2 different classifications of unions because the skilled trades are nothing like the other ones but we all get clumped together which is bullshit. When is the lastime you heard of a problem or anykind of bullshit going on or happening about a skilled trade union? Never it is always the unions that are permanent year round workers like i mentioned above.