Look at it this way, Dan. Kyle sends Eric a PM while he is online. He also saw Eric online checking PMs (yes, moderators can see when you are checking PMs, but we cannot see your PMs). He sees him online several times during the 24 hour time limit. I can imagine Kyle felt pretty foolish waiting around when he knows Eric has seen the PM and has had ample opportunity to respond. It seems to me if Eric had any intention of responding to Kyle's PM, he would have done it long before he was banned. I doubt he had any intention of responding, and I believe he justused the ban as an excuse for why he didn't respond. I guess my confusion is why you so whole-heartedly believe the word of someone who has shown he isn't trustworty.