I use a pancake cooled that is no larger than 12"x12" using 5/16" line
To cool my tranny
I've ran electric fans and switched back to a clutch fan the fan choice made no difference
I have daily driven in heavy traffic and city driving I have towed at up to 31k gross
Truck is some where around 500+ hp
I have chnged the fluid about 8 times I've ran amsoil, Mopar, and finally AutoZone special in a 5gal bucket I add redlube to the silver bottle to my results are the same
My tranny has almost 100k on it now
It holds perfect with no slippage I'm in oklahoma add our temps vary greatly last summer we almost broke the record for the hottest ever in the US we saw many days where temps were 110+
We also have some pretty cold winters although we don't get down in the negatives to often it has been known to happen
N e way I have never seen my tranny temp rise above 190 and that was sitting in traffic most of the time my 140-320 gauge never moves off the 140 peg
I have never pulled excessive shavings from the oil and it is always red never brown
I also have a friend that has ran a tranny shop for the past 30yrs and he has pulled heat exchAngers as a matter of practice for quite some time now.
I am not Trying to argue one way or another I just want to share my experience in hopes that someone including me might walk away with a better understanding
This is a great thread
All the information you just posted goes against everything I have learned and tested. I have done a lot of testing and work closely with Setrab coolers.
My specialty for 30 years was Mercedes transmissions along with BMW, Jaguar, and Rolls Royce with some Ferraris thrown in. My shop was a GM transmission warranty station for 15 years. I hung around with the GM engineers. We did a lot of work for Ford dealers when they had problems.
I got involved with diesels back in 1990 and realy persued them in 1999. I learned from the best diesel specialists and in '01 was in on the ground floor with the Allison. Back then we had Transgo, ATS, Suncoast, big Dipper and myself doing R@D on the Alli. I think I know what I talk about.