Why you would NOT upgrade your turbo

Idaho CTD

Junkie
May 28, 2008
179
0
0
Idaho
Don't forget you can't introduce N20 as smoothly as boost. Even with progressive controllers it is big shots of N20 just not all at once. Solenoids are open or closed and are pulsed for the ramp rate. So while it helps to smooth the introduction it's not totally smooth. I personally think the spikes in power caused by the introduction of N20 causes huge spikes in CP and damage to hard parts. It seems like progressive controllers have really helped with motor life though.
 

Fingers

Village Idiot
Vendor/Sponsor
Apr 1, 2008
1,717
96
48
White Oak, PA
There are a couple factors in CP that must be taken into consideration. This from my measurements. Going from 20-40 PSI boost does not increase CP 1000 PSI. Mainly because the compression in not Adiabatic. It does increase though, the total amount is a function of how hot the chamber walls, piston and head have gotten. The cooler the chamber, the closer to isothemal compression.

The other is the "kick" from a given amount of fuel as boost comes up. The kick looks to be related to the pre-burn pressure and not the boost itself. And that is the interesting part. More boost keeps the chamber cooler and thus the peak pressures. Al that with the same fuel loading.

I will have to look at a lot more data to weed out all the factors, but that is my gross assessment.
 

JoshH

Daggum farm truck
Staff member
Vendor/Sponsor
Feb 14, 2007
13,716
779
113
Texas!!!
There are a couple factors in CP that must be taken into consideration. This from my measurements. Going from 20-40 PSI boost does not increase CP 1000 PSI. Mainly because the compression in not Adiabatic. It does increase though, the total amount is a function of how hot the chamber walls, piston and head have gotten. The cooler the chamber, the closer to isothemal compression.

The other is the "kick" from a given amount of fuel as boost comes up. The kick looks to be related to the pre-burn pressure and not the boost itself. And that is the interesting part. More boost keeps the chamber cooler and thus the peak pressures. Al that with the same fuel loading.

I will have to look at a lot more data to weed out all the factors, but that is my gross assessment.
Yeah, but what do you know? LOL

Interesting info.
 

Stingpuller

The Pusher Man
Jan 11, 2007
2,019
35
48
57
central Ohio
Nos

NOS if done correct, with the right parts is no harder on parts than a big turbo making the same power. FACT! I just got back from dynoing my truck(over 500 miles) and made 890hp. Yes with nos but made 750 without. That to me is big power with being able to drive it that far. That was a single stage smallish jet. I will make over 1000 next time! God I love diesel trucks that you can actually drive. Jeff
 

Kat

Wicked Witch of the West
Aug 2, 2006
17,899
13
38
60
Norco, CA
NOS if done correct, with the right parts is no harder on parts than a big turbo making the same power. FACT! I just got back from dynoing my truck(over 500 miles) and made 890hp. Yes with nos but made 750 without. That to me is big power with being able to drive it that far. That was a single stage smallish jet. I will make over 1000 next time! God I love diesel trucks that you can actually drive. Jeff

Congrats Jeff :rockon:
 

codyn

Member
Aug 26, 2007
412
0
16
urbana ohio
NOS if done correct, with the right parts is no harder on parts than a big turbo making the same power. FACT! I just got back from dynoing my truck(over 500 miles) and made 890hp. Yes with nos but made 750 without. That to me is big power with being able to drive it that far. That was a single stage smallish jet. I will make over 1000 next time! God I love diesel trucks that you can actually drive. Jeff

congrats
 

Diesel power

New member
Jun 2, 2008
855
0
0
maryland
http://members.cox.net/td-eoc/compression spreadheet.xls

I have come to some initial conclusions, but if you look at what happens when you increase boost or IAT, you get eye-popping realities.

For example, going from 20 to 40 psi of boost (20 psi increase) increases TDC compression by 1000 psi, a 50 fold impact.

A 50 deg temp increase due to the lower efficiency of higher compression, means going from an IAT of 150 to 200. This increases compressed temp 4 fold, from 1450 to 1620F.

I did this in a quest to determine how turbocharging kills motors, and it becomes obvious. It also lends a strong argument to N2O (not a fuel), which lowers charge temp, and doesn't increase cylinder pressure before combustion like a turbo does.

Open for discussion.

Exactly!!!!!

Im glad im not the only one who thinks that way....
 

Diesel power

New member
Jun 2, 2008
855
0
0
maryland
High CP before TDC brakes parts...

High CP after TDC makes power...

Nitrous does not increase compression(CP) before TDC(at least it shouldent if done correctly)unless the fuel is igniting too soon( too much timming......which is recipie for big problems..
But it should increase after/around TDC( if done correctly)because the extra oxygen from the nitrous capitalizes on the unburnt fuel and completes the combustion resulting in more power on the power stroke!
 

Diesel power

New member
Jun 2, 2008
855
0
0
maryland
Also , yea boost is important, but drive pressure is a often over looked demon that will ruin a engine in the blink of an eye.

too much BP and the resulting lack of exhaust will stack on the intake and compression side of the stroke REALLY causeing high CP before TDC and yet again braking parts.

this is why i allways increase the AR or size of the exhaust housing a bit to compensate for higher BP with the use of nitrous, and yes i have seen big Gains in BP with just a 50-75HP shot of the white stuff.....let alone more!!!

But what do i know......im just a guy thats builds golf cart engines......:rofl:
 

racinmike77

New member
Sep 14, 2008
1,029
0
0
MD
http://members.cox.net/td-eoc/compression spreadheet.xls

I have come to some initial conclusions, but if you look at what happens when you increase boost or IAT, you get eye-popping realities.

For example, going from 20 to 40 psi of boost (20 psi increase) increases TDC compression by 1000 psi, a 50 fold impact.

A 50 deg temp increase due to the lower efficiency of higher compression, means going from an IAT of 150 to 200. This increases compressed temp 4 fold, from 1450 to 1620F.

I did this in a quest to determine how turbocharging kills motors, and it becomes obvious. It also lends a strong argument to N2O (not a fuel), which lowers charge temp, and doesn't increase cylinder pressure before combustion like a turbo does.

Open for discussion.

did you stop and think that at 30psi the stock turbo and GT42 turbo do not move the same amount of air?
 

MAXLLY

No Lemming Here
Aug 15, 2007
1,063
0
0
San Diego
BAck in the day the same stuff happened to gasser nitrous cars... kept breaking stuff melting stuff. If we take baby steps we'll figure it out.

Diesel Power appears to have Won several coveted trophies using nitrous.

Nitrous is cold, can do low timing and burns fuel fast and late. Sounds like a winner to me on the premature CP front. Smooth nitrous delivery isn't an issue anymore, we can do 3-5 stages purdy easy and trigger it with ALL kinds of things.

Big boost, big nitrous, big chargers whatever sooner or later its gonna break stuff.

I vote nitrous as my method of adding air, after all thats all it is... COLD air in a bottle. Versus hot air from a charger/chargers.
 

LarryJewell

Back with his honey :)
Jan 21, 2007
10,152
0
36
58
San Angelo
wonder what would happen to a modded vvt turbo if we kept our modfied desired boost and vane tables; and also used the boost sensor scaling table from the mcrat 20/20 tow tune :confused:

This is assuming that we are aquiring decent drive pressure readings prior to using this boost sensor scaling table :D
 

Fingers

Village Idiot
Vendor/Sponsor
Apr 1, 2008
1,717
96
48
White Oak, PA
did you stop and think that at 30psi the stock turbo and GT42 turbo do not move the same amount of air?

+/- the efficiency, yes they do flow the same lb/min at the same RPM. Even with a significant difference in efficiency, the CAC would bring them within points of each other.
 

Diesel power

New member
Jun 2, 2008
855
0
0
maryland
BAck in the day the same stuff happened to gasser nitrous cars... kept breaking stuff melting stuff. If we take baby steps we'll figure it out.

Diesel Power appears to have Won several coveted trophies using nitrous.

Nitrous is cold, can do low timing and burns fuel fast and late. Sounds like a winner to me on the premature CP front. Smooth nitrous delivery isn't an issue anymore, we can do 3-5 stages purdy easy and trigger it with ALL kinds of things.

Big boost, big nitrous, big chargers whatever sooner or later its gonna break stuff.

I vote nitrous as my method of adding air, after all thats all it is... COLD air in a bottle. Versus hot air from a charger/chargers.

All i can say is that your truck is gonna turn some heads with a little nitrous tuning.......