I think stretched tires on wide wheels looks dumb. I also think the 5 spoke LML wheel is fugly. Now everyone can hate on me.
FWIW, I ran a 305/50R20 on a 9" wide wheel, and it wore the center out of the tread in about 20-25k miles on two completely different brands of tire. I stepped it down to a 285/55, and it wears perfect now. No, the tire was not run over-inflated. My personal opinion is a 12" wide wheel is a little too wide for a 305, but that's more of a looks opinion than it is a safety opinion. I'm sure it is perfectly safe if the manufacturer lists that tire fitting that size wheel.
FWIW, I ran a 305/50R20 on a 9" wide wheel, and it wore the center out of the tread in about 20-25k miles on two completely different brands of tire. I stepped it down to a 285/55, and it wears perfect now. No, the tire was not run over-inflated. My personal opinion is a 12" wide wheel is a little too wide for a 305, but that's more of a looks opinion than it is a safety opinion. I'm sure it is perfectly safe if the manufacturer lists that tire fitting that size wheel.