forged pistons?

Stingpuller

The Pusher Man
Jan 11, 2007
2,019
35
48
57
central Ohio
Motors

You can not even compare what a motor takes drag racing vs pulling! You will never load a motor pulling like you will drag racing. Pullers hurt'em also just not as often. Pulling your motor is up and never comes down. Well it shouldn't come down at the end:D. Drag racing the motor goes up then down many times with a big load in the big gears! That's why so many drag guys want to run the 1/8. They hardly ever break at that point of the run. Same goes for trannies! Pulling is a hole lot easier on a tranny than drag racing. Jeff
 

Rhall

Old Skooler
Aug 12, 2006
2,241
0
36
41
Texas Y'all
Id agree, pulling is a lot easier on a motor, Although i did see some pretty high boost numbers, and the tracks around here you will pull your engine down at the end if your geared right, i managed to completly expand a set of big bellows, the same ones Rick puts on his up pipes, i could never expand the aftermarket ones with the twins drag racing, but i had a pretty hard season of drag racing on my cut pistons too. When they fail ill def go forged, if i get another season out of them ill be happy, it sounds like some forged pistons dont get much more than 2 to 3 seasons.
 

sweetdiesel

That's better
Aug 6, 2006
10,390
0
0
52
Thailand
thanks for your input Jeff, I really appreciate it. I was under the impression that when Simon tore his down he had scored the cylinder(s) because the rings wore so much.


Mine is not tore down yet. It will be in the next month or so.

We are down on compression a bit and I'm just assuming it's the rings.

I'll post up what I find after we get the heads off
 

Micheal Tomac

been pulling forever
Aug 12, 2008
273
0
16
MI
I got three seasons on a new set of OEM cut LB7 pistons with 16.8:1 compression. During the pistons third season (2009) I torched a hole in one and a couple months later I cracked another one. I think the cut cast pistons will only last only so many hooks, 1/4 mile runs and WOT passes.
 

RENODMAX

Dead Wrong
Mar 4, 2008
3,602
0
0
Talk to Fingers. He has some testing and stock pistons are actually WEAKER when delipped/cut. Also there are people staying with higher compression pistons and having some very good luck. I dont really know why everyone assumes a stock cut/coated piston is the way to go?
 

sweetdiesel

That's better
Aug 6, 2006
10,390
0
0
52
Thailand
the way i look at forged is if you want a race truck DONT try and use stock pistons that are not intended for racing.....no matter what you do you still have a stock piston JMHO
 

Rhall

Old Skooler
Aug 12, 2006
2,241
0
36
41
Texas Y'all
Talk to Fingers. He has some testing and stock pistons are actually WEAKER when delipped/cut. Also there are people staying with higher compression pistons and having some very good luck. I dont really know why everyone assumes a stock cut/coated piston is the way to go?

I dont think anybody is saying they're the way to go, the debate here is wether or not the 2k plus is worth it to go forged, and what brand of forged pistons to run.
 

Stingpuller

The Pusher Man
Jan 11, 2007
2,019
35
48
57
central Ohio
Pistons

Rob, First I didn't mean you were not making any power because you are making a lot! Anything can be broken in short order is something is not rite. It's just crazy sometimes to think something making 1000hp will last a long time. Take any motor and make 3 times the power and see how long they last. Jeff
 

Rhall

Old Skooler
Aug 12, 2006
2,241
0
36
41
Texas Y'all
Rob, First I didn't mean you were not making any power because you are making a lot! Anything can be broken in short order is something is not rite. It's just crazy sometimes to think something making 1000hp will last a long time. Take any motor and make 3 times the power and see how long they last. Jeff

Oh i didnt take it as that at all, i was just joking around! I want to go with forged in my motor, im just not in a hurry to do it. If i can get 3 seasons out of cast pistons, (which im not saying that will happen everytime) what would be the benifit of going forged seeing that some are only getting 2 to 3 also? It seems that Arias are holding up better than that, so that might be my option when i go that direction, but if its not broke, im probably not going to fix it.
 

IOWA LLY

Yes, its really me
Feb 23, 2007
2,275
4
0
I have 2 1/2 seasons on my forged Mahle's. I can't comment on how they look though as I haven't torn the motor down since it was built mid 08. No issues so far with them though.
 

kjp800

-
Aug 6, 2008
525
0
0
New Jersey
Talk to Fingers. He has some testing and stock pistons are actually WEAKER when delipped/cut. Also there are people staying with higher compression pistons and having some very good luck. I dont really know why everyone assumes a stock cut/coated piston is the way to go?

Any more info on this? I seem to be hearing more and more about trucks running stock un-cut pistions
 

WolfLMM

Making Chips
Nov 21, 2006
4,005
25
48
38
AL
Talk to Fingers. He has some testing and stock pistons are actually WEAKER when delipped/cut. Also there are people staying with higher compression pistons and having some very good luck. I dont really know why everyone assumes a stock cut/coated piston is the way to go?

Of course they are. You are removing material, that some engineer got paid big bucks to put there. I don't mean to rain on anyone's parade, but come on.