My experience, and everyone else’s that I know that actually uses trailers every day are the exact opposite of what you guys are saying. Around here we say PJ stands for Pure Junk. The PJ trailers are junk. I was looking at my buddies PJ a little bit ago because he barely bumped a tree with it and the whole rear sill folded in, anyway, while looking at it I noticed that it was made in Mexico. He ended up getting an H&H and loves it. Another buddy has a Load Trail and a PJ and he says they are the worst trailers he’s ever had, and he’s a landscaper using them everyday, so he’s very familiar with equipment. When I was looking at buying a new gooseneck I just stopped and looked at a new PJ for kicks and giggles, and they welded c-channel end-to-end because they didn’t have a long enough piece, and the build quality was horrible. I was looking at more PJ trailers a bit later and the axles were off side to side about 3/4”, I had to check it again because I couldn’t believe it and sure enough, it was. And all the trailers on the lot were like that! Some were a bit better, but most weren’t.
I’ve had one of my H&H trailers which is a gooseneck since it was brand new in ‘04, I’ve put probably 40K miles on it, pulled it in the winter, loaded it with all sorts of different equipment, grossed the trailer weight at 23K pounds (it’s a 14K trailer), pulled a camper or boat behind it for thousands of miles and used it for so many things I can’t even remember, and yet, not long ago I had a guy ask me it the trailer was new lol, it still looks that nice.
A tire buddy of mine could break a solid chunk of steel with the way he abuses stuff, I told him to get an H&H dump trailer. He bought a used one and even after using it for 6 or 7 years now, he still hasn’t broken it, although I did rewire it for him because some brake wires got pinched, caused a short and fried.
Another buddy has an H&H dump and loves it.
I have a very large enclosed H&H and that thing pulls so nice and smooth. Friends with other enclosed trailers were breaking tools left and right because their trailers rode so rough and they ended up selling the trailer. I can leave tools on top of my work benches, drive 50 miles and the tool doesn’t budge.
The thing to remember is that H&H does have different lines. They used to only make top of the line trailers, but to compete with all the other manufacturers out there they had to come out with cheaper lines. So know what you are buying. I’ve never had anyone ever say that an H&H is poor quality, however everybody that actually uses equipment that I know says how bad both Load Trail and PJ are, and these guys have owned them, so they are talking from experience.