So what do you do? Literally buff it out?
I've been on a wheel-buying binge these past couple months, since I was putting winter tires on the family's cars. $75 for a set of Pontiac GP wheels in better condition than my daughter's regular ones, $100 for a set of OEM 16s in great shape for my son's G6, and $175 for a set of --Im not kidding -- 2014 Buick Regal 17s in absolutely brand new condition for my wifes Malibu. Then winter tires for all. Yes, I spent some $$, but did a boatload of research and found deals on all the tires. My family's safety is paramount to me. I even broke down and bought winter tires for my Cruze, I dunno, maybe b/c I like driving it over BBT (please dont tell the truck that, ok?).
So, Im searching Craiglist for the hell of it b/c I was bored, and came across a set of 18x8 Buick Verano 10-spoke machine face wheels with tires for $200. I couldnt pass them up. Texted the guy and offered $150, we settled on $160. The wheels ended up being even better condition than what the pictures showed. The tires are usable (but I'll be buying new though), TPMS sensors and all 20 stock lugnuts. Hell, the Cruze center caps fit these wheels, too.
To me, these are a sizable improvement in looks over the OEM Cruze 17s.