What does exhaust size have to do with him having a stock motor? There is no benefit to 5" unless your running a true full 5". All the 5" exhaust on a duramax start out as 4" and then change to 5" after the transmission cross member. Its been said time and time again that 4" in a plenty, but 5" is for a different sound and of course looks.
Don't understand what your point is? I agree 4" is plenty for 95% of all dmax trucks, and not all 5" starts at the cross member at least not on my truck. There is very little difference in sound between a 4" and 5" and if it important to look like your "packin" to impress the girls put one of those goofy big ass tips on the exhaust. This kid is new and just trying to help him spend his money wisely to upgrade the performance of his truck. I guess it's more important to look good rather than run good for some folks. :thumb: