The Stage 5s from those 3 have the same brand of clutches, clutch counts, and pressure mods as the old school SunCoast Stage 4 kits, yet they rate them at higher power capabilities. Holding for a dyno pull doesn't mean anything, look at the stock transmissions that hold 500+ on the dyno or Dimitri who can dyno 20 times on the same trans at max effort but goes to the track and burns it up with the power turned down some. In my opinion SunCoast is more accurate in their power holding capabilities. The other kits don't have a wavy plate for the C2, which depending on the rest of your setup can cause C2s to come on too hard - which is what strips the hub/planet. The Alligator kit doesn't look like (and they didn't tell me otherwise when I called to get the specs) it has thicker C3 or C4 apply plates or shorter pistons. The stock apply plates bow in the center when applied and put more pressure on the center of the clutches than the outside, which is why stock clutches are always more burnt in the center. Thicker plates prevent that bowing and put more even pressure on the clutches to use their entire surface area as much and as equally as possible.
For the same $2220 I know where you could get an actual SunCoast Stage IV kit (not an Alto reverse engineered copy of one) with a Precision Industries converter.
Another big thing to consider when shopping around for the cheapest kit is this:
If you plan to take your truck to a shop that specializes in performance Allison builds to have it done it will most likely be the cheapest total out of your pocket, especially up front, if you let them get the kit and converter for you. When they quote a trans build out the door price they may break it down on your invoice or price quote as $3000 for parts and $1000 for labor or whatever, but if you bring them a kit you will most likely pay more than $1000 for labor. Their out the door price is with all of their expenses and time considered - parts including shipping, shipping cores back, fluids, ect; then they mark it up what they feel is fair for the time and expertise it takes to do it. If you buy the parts and fluids through them they are making a portion of their profit on those parts, and if they are a shop that's been around a while they are getting the parts cheaper than you can get the "cheaper kits", and if they order enough of them at once or stock the kits they may not even be paying shipping. Now if you buy your own parts they want to make the same total money - their time and expertise hasn't changed, if anything it gets longer installing a kit they aren't familiar with or have to mess with clearances more than usual with - now you are paying them more in labor by more than what you saved on the kit. Then you have to pay the core charges ($500) up front, shipping ($75 from DMax Store to 32566), and the shipping to return your core parts ($40+).
So if you are shopping around for a kit to install yourself or for "Joe's Transmission Shop" or the local Allison stock rebuild shop who told you that they'll do it if you provide the kit - by all means try to get the best deal you can on a good quality kit (which may not mean buying a "cheaper" kit). But if you are getting it built by a reputable performance Allison shop trust that if they could get a better deal on the same quality of kit as what they use, they would be doing it and giving you a cheaper out the door price.