the general concencous seems to just come down to which ever you find cheaper. both seem to work well and both have people who dont like one or the other.
Nittos all the way. I have run both and the Nitto wears better and has way better wet road traction.
Neither are good for lots of heavy towing miles. Too much center wear with a non "LT" tire. They can hold the weight but flex too much in the center due to round shoulders.